Every year, hundreds of thousands of people in Germany receive a decision from their long-term care insurance fund - and many are disappointed. The awarded care grade is often lower than expected. Estimates suggest this affects about one in three applicants. The consequences are serious: less care allowance and limited access to in-kind benefits, assistive devices, or respite services. But there is good news: appealing an incorrect care grade is not only possible, but worthwhile in many cases. Around 29–30% of appeals result in a correction in favor of people in need of care.
The Medical Service (MD) or Medicproof usually conducts the assessment in just 45–60 minutes. As a result, fluctuations in day-to-day functioning (especially with dementia, pain, or mental illnesses) can easily be underestimated. Formal errors in scoring the six modules (mobility, cognitive abilities, behaviors, self-care, coping with the consequences of illness, managing everyday life) can also occur. Just one additional point can be enough to move into the next care grade - and receive hundreds of euros more per month. Often, the problem is not just the short assessment time, but also incomplete information in the application or the assessor failing to consider all relevant aspects, such as care needs at night or seasonal deterioration. In such cases, a well-prepared appeal can help correct the situation and secure the benefits you are entitled to.
Tip: Keep a detailed care diary even before submitting your application. It will later be your strongest evidence. Record not only daily activities, but also specific support needs, the duration of assistance, and the people involved - this will make your case irrefutable.

Why an appeal is worthwhile - common reasons and chances of success
An incorrect care level often results from systematic problems in the assessment process. The assessor spends only a limited amount of time on site, resulting in a snapshot that does not reflect everyday life. "Good days" are particularly likely to be overestimated in fluctuating conditions such as multiple sclerosis or Parkinson's disease. In addition, medical records are sometimes not taken sufficiently into account, or points in the assessment modules are added up incorrectly. The consequences: A care level that is too low means not only financial losses, but also less support in the form of care services, assistive devices, or respite care, making everyday life unnecessarily difficult for people in need of care and their relatives. Based on statistics from the Medical Service for 2022 to 2025, the success rate is around 29–30%, although there are regional differences - in some federal states, advisory services such as VdK even achieve 30–35%. With a strong case and supporting evidence, the chances increase considerably, especially when only a few points are needed for a higher classification. Many cases are corrected during the appeals process, without having to go to court. So it is worth taking action, as a successful correction applies retroactively from the application date and can result in back payments.Meeting deadlines - the first and most important step
As soon as the decision arrives in your mailbox, the clock starts ticking. You have one month from the date of delivery to file an objection. The deadline does not start on the postmark date, but when the decision is actually received (usually 3–4 days after dispatch). If you miss this deadline, the decision becomes final. Only in exceptional cases (e.g., if information on legal remedies is missing) is it extended to one year. If the decision has formal defects – such as missing reasons, no assessment attached, or no signature – this may be an additional reason to object immediately, as such errors may render the decision invalid. The initial objection can be filed informally – a short letter is enough: “I hereby object to the decision dated [Datum], file reference [Nr.], and request access to the files and a new assessment.” Send it by registered mail with return receipt or via your care insurance provider’s online portal. Many providers have offered digital submissions since 2023/2024. An informal submission protects the deadline while you prepare the detailed justification. The person entitled to file the objection may be the person requiring care, an authorized representative, a lawyer, or a legal guardian – relatives without power of attorney cannot do so on their own. More information on the detailed steps for objecting to a care level assessment is available in the guide from Pflege.de.Reviewing the assessment – this is where most errors occur
Within 14 days of filing the objection, you are entitled to access to the files (the complete MD/Medicproof assessment and all records). Check carefully:- Are the points in the sections correct? Check the total – calculation errors often distort the overall score (e.g., thresholds: care level 2 from 27 points, level 3 from 47.5).
- Were fluctuations or nighttime burdens taken into account? Many assessments ignore variable symptoms or irregular needs.
- Did the assessor contact your family doctor or care service? Failure to consult external sources is a frequent point of criticism.
- Are there inaccuracies in the description? Compare it with your care diary to document any discrepancies.
Writing a strong justification – the key to success
You should submit the detailed justification no later than one month after filing the informal objection. Here, list specifically where the assessment differs from reality and provide evidence with:- Care diary entries (with date and time) describing daily support needs in detail, including duration and frequency.
- Medical certificates, discharge letters, medication plans or specialist reports substantiating your health condition.
- Statements from family members or caregivers confirming your daily life.
- Photos/videos (in compliance with data protection rules) showing assistive devices or limitations.
Preparing for the reassessment
If your objection is successful, the health insurance fund usually orders a new assessment. Prepare well:- Schedule the appointment for a “bad” day (when symptoms are worse) to reflect reality.
- Involve everyone relevant, such as family members or caregivers who can describe your daily life.
- Keep documents close at hand, including new medical certificates or updates on your health.
- Speak openly and honestly about your actual daily life – without exaggerating. Demonstrate your needs naturally, for example by showing your limitations.
- Do not accept a telephone assessment – request a home visit.

What happens next?
The health insurance fund has up to three months. If the decision is positive, you will receive the higher benefits retroactively from the date of your application. If your application is denied, you will receive a notice of objection – you can then take the matter to the Social Court (free of charge, filing deadline: 1 month). Your chances improve significantly with a lawyer and an independent care expert (often to 60–70%). The court can order another assessment or amend the decision directly. In exceptional cases, a claim can even be filed retroactively for up to four years if new evidence is available.
Current regulations 2025/2026
Since July 1, 2025, there has been a shared annual budget of up to €3,539 for respite and short-term care - flexible to use, with no prior-care period required and half of the care allowance continuing to be paid for up to eight weeks. Since January 1, 2026, two care consultations per year (every six months) apply uniformly for care grades 2-5, regardless of grade - a relief, since higher grades previously required quarterly appointments. The care allowance remains unchanged in 2026: €347 (PG 2), €599 (PG 3), €800 (PG 4), €990 (PG 5). Under the BEEP Act (Act on Expanding Powers and Reducing Bureaucracy in Long-Term Care), from 2026 the competencies of care professionals will expand (e.g., in wound care), documentation requirements will be reduced digitally, and preventive measures in home care will be strengthened. In Bavaria, the state care allowance will be halved to €500 per year. Retroactive claims for respite care are limited to the current and previous calendar year.
You can find more information about changes to long-term care from July 1, 2025, including the shared budget for respite and short-term care, on the website of the Federal Ministry of Health: https://www.bundesgesundheitsministerium.de/presse/pressemitteilungen/das-aendert-sich-zum-1-juli-in-der-pflege.html
You can find more information about changes to long-term care from 2026, including the standardization of care consultations and the BEEP Act, on Pflege.de: https://www.pflege.de/pflegekasse-pflegefinanzierung/pflegeleistungen/pflege-2026/
Why the fight is worth it: Conclusion and motivation
An incorrect care grade is not an unchangeable fate - on the contrary: Many people affected have achieved a fair reassessment through a well-founded objection or even a lawsuit before the social court, gaining not only financial relief but also a better quality of life for themselves and their relatives. The statistics speak for themselves: Almost one in three objections leads to a correction, and in cases with professional support (e.g., from VdK, independent experts, or lawyers), success rates are often 50% or higher. Remember: Every additional point on the assessment tool can mean hundreds of euros more per month - and you are legally entitled to these benefits if your actual needs are proven.
The process may seem bureaucratic and exhausting at first, but it is manageable: With a detailed care diary, medical evidence, a clear explanation, and, if needed, outside support (free at many advice centers), you have a real chance. Many people later regret simply accepting the decision, so take action early. Every day counts, because if your objection is successful, the higher benefits will be paid retroactively. Exercise your rights—you are not alone: Advice centers, hotlines, and online guides are there to help. The path to the right care level is often shorter than it seems.